Menu Close

Postpartum Psychosis : Why the Lindsay Clancy Conversation Can't Stop Here

Publish Date: October 15, 2026
Author: Dr. Jeffrey Lieberman
Source: Shrink Speak substack

Postpartum psychosis made the headlines this summer. But as Nyna Giles and I outline in an article for the LA Times, the conversation has been carrying on for far too many decades.

I recently co-authored an article for the LA Times with Nyna Giles, author of The Bridesmaid’s Daughter, about postpartum psychosis and some of the high-profile women who have suffered from it over the last half-century. It's worth your time, and I'd encourage you to read it in full at the LA Times (subscription may be required).

Here's why it matters.

This summer, a Massachusetts courtroom made postpartum psychosis a national topic of discussion. For the first time since perhaps the Andrea Yates trial of 2006, wherein Yates's 2002 murder conviction was overturned and she was found NGRI (not guilty by reason of insanity), the topic of postpartum psychosis gripped the national psyche as Lindsay Clancy went on trial for the triple murder of her children.

The circumstances that led to the conversation were horrific, yet I couldn't help but find myself glad to find the average American actively discussing postpartum psychosis. It is a rare disease, but like any psychosis, it can prove debilitating – and in cases like Yates's and, as I am convinced is true, Lindsay Clancy's, it can end in needless tragedy.

Childbirth is the most pervasively influential life event short of death. There is nothing that changes a woman's life more irrevocably – and the adjustments that a woman must make in the aftermath of childbirth and at the start of motherhood are challenging even for the most mentally healthy and stable woman. When a mental disorder enters this picture, the situation can be dire.

Despite this danger, far too great a percentage of the public has historically had an inadequate understanding of postpartum psychosis, how to identify it, and when to seek help. Therein lay the reason for the encouragement I felt at the national interest in postpartum psychosis.

But Lindsay Clancy's trial ended without an answer, finishing in a mistrial after the jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict. Whether to try her again is now up to the Plymouth County district attorney.

The legal story yet remains unfinished. But regardless of its final outcome, the risk is that the public story ends here, as the cameras and the nation’s attention move on to the next sensational headline.

That would be a mistake, because the Clancy case was never only about one family. Postpartum psychosis is rare, affecting roughly one or two of every thousand women, but it is a genuine psychiatric emergency, and it often strikes without warning. Although prior mental health struggles can prove an accelerant for postpartum psychosis, they are not a universal trigger, and some mothers may find the disease to be their first real experience with mental illness.

Mothers and their families may also lack understanding of how seriously they must regard this disease and its treatment regimen. The recent Times Square stabbing incident, for example, perpetrated by Pamela Cisneros and resulting in the deaths of Cisneros and one of her victims, points to another possible case of postpartum-driven mental illness. Cisneros had been taking medication for years, but her family suspects she may have stopped her treatment suddenly a few months prior to the incident. Had Cisneros or her family fully understood the stakes of neglecting treatment, perhaps the Times Square tragedy could have been avoided.

Despite the attention the Lindsay Clancy case brought to postpartum psychosis, real change will need the backing of public pressure that outlasts a news cycle.

The good news is that postpartum psychosis can be cured. Screening is neither expensive nor difficult. Yet it is not standard for hospitals to provide it, nor are families usually warned about the disease. And that is exactly why the conversation can’t stop here. Early detection depends on doctors who know to look for it, families who know the warning signs, and a system that responds effectively when a new mother asks for help – yet we neglect to provide that care.

Despite the attention the Lindsay Clancy case brought to postpartum psychosis, real change will need the backing of public pressure that outlasts a news cycle. That is why ARETÉ Science exists: to build a future where all Americans have access to the mental health care we already have the knowledge and means to provide.

In the meantime, here's one thing we can all do: keep talking about postpartum psychosis with your partner, your OB, and your friends and family who are expecting. The next case of postpartum psychosis doesn't have to end the way Lindsay Clancy's did.


Read more articles on the Shrink Speak substack >